| C1 | Christ the Lord Is Born | Sufjan Stevens | 0:48 |
| C2 | Christmas Woman | Sufjan Stevens | 5:33 |
| C3 | Break Forth O Beauteous Heavenly Light | Sufjan Stevens | 1:09 |
| C4 | Happy Family Christmas | Sufjan Stevens | 1:22 |
| C5 | Jingle Bells | Sufjan Stevens | 1:18 |
| C6 | Mysteries of the Christmas Mist | Sufjan Stevens | 2:10 |
| C7 | Lift Up Your Heads Ye Mighty Gates | Sufjan Stevens | 1:20 |
| C8 | We Wish You a Merry Christmas | Sufjan Stevens | 1:16 |
| C9 | Ah Holy Jesus | Sufjan Stevens | 2:41 |
| C10 | Behold! the Birth of Man, the Face of Glory | Sufjan Stevens | 1:08 |
| C11 | Ding‐A‐Ling‐A‐Ring‐A‐Ling | Sufjan Stevens | 1:49 |
| D12 | How Shall I Fitly Meet Thee? | Sufjan Stevens | 2:09 |
| D13 | Mr. Frosty Man | Sufjan Stevens | 1:49 |
| D14 | Make Haste to See the Baby | Sufjan Stevens | 1:22 |
| D15 | Ah Holy Jesus (with reed organ) | Sufjan Stevens | 1:28 |
| D16 | Hark! The Herald Angels Sing | Sufjan Stevens | 1:50 |
| D17 | Morning L.M. (sacred harp) | Sufjan Stevens | 2:27 |
| D18 | Idumea S.M. (sacred harp) | Sufjan Stevens | 3:50 |
| D19 | Eternal Happiness or Woe | Sufjan Stevens | 1:22 |
| D20 | Ah Holy Jesus (a cappella) | Sufjan Stevens | 0:59 |
| D21 | I Am Santa’s Helper (You Are Santa’s Slave) | Sufjan Stevens | 1:51 |
| D22 | “Maoz Tzur” (Rock of Ages) | Sufjan Stevens | 0:42 |
| D23 | Even the Earth Will Perish and the Universe Give Way | Sufjan Stevens | 2:00 |