| 1 | All I Want for Christmas Is Positions (Ariana Grande vs. Mariah Carey) | Adamusic | — |
| 2 | I Like Christmas (Cardi B vs. Mariah Carey) | Al Colle | — |
| 3 | All I Want for Christmas Is to F**k You (Lily Allen vs. Mariah Carey) | AL Mashups | — |
| 4 | All I Want for Christmas Is the Beautiful People (Marilyn Manson vs. Mariah Carey) | Bill McClintock | — |
| 5 | Hot N’ Christmas (Katy Perry vs. Mariah Carey) | Chris Thompson | — |
| 6 | All I Want for Christmas Is a Bonfire (Childish Gambino vs. Mariah Carey) | Content Channel | — |
| 7 | All I Want for Christmas Is Anaconda (Nicki Minaj vs. Mariah Carey) | DEMASHUP | — |
| 8 | All I Want for Christmas Is Mr. Brightside (The Killers vs. Mariah Carey) | Devon Ireland | — |
| 9 | All I Want for Christmas Is to Bury a Friend (Mariah Carey vs. Billie Eilish) | DJ Cummerbund | — |
| 10 | All I Want for September Is to Wake Up (Green Day vs. Mariah Carey) | DJ Cummerbund | — |
| 11 | Scarey Xmas (Mariah Carey vs. Dillinja and Unknown Error) | DJ NoNo | — |
| 12 | Don’t Stop Christmas Now (Queen vs. Mariah Carey) | Exightly | — |
| 13 | All I Want for Christmas Is Psychosocial (Slipknot vs. Mariah Carey) | froosti | — |
| 14 | All iSpy for Christmas (Kyle ft. Lil Yachty vs. Mariah Carey) | Grave Danger | — |
| 15 | All I Want for Christmas Is Bass Music (Mariah Carey vs. Herobust vs. Boombox Cartel) | IamJstncrdble | — |
| 16 | All I Want for Christmas Mashup (Jessie J vs. Carly Rae Jepsen vs. Rita Ora vs. Cash Cash, Bebe Rexha vs. Macklemore & Ryan Lewis vs. Mariah Carey) | Jamie Booth | — |
| 17 | All I Want for Christmas Is You x I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Whitney Houston vs. Mariah Carey) | Jimmy Press Play | — |
| 18 | All I Want for Christmas Is WAP (Cardi B & Megan Thee Stallion vs. Mariah Carey) | Lewis Wake | — |
| 19 | All I Want Is Combination Xmas Hut and Taco Bells (Das Racist vs. Mariah Carey) | DJ Lobsterdust | — |
| 20 | Golden Christmas (Harry Styles vs. Mariah Carey) | Logan Mashups | — |
| 21 | Christmas in Paris (Kanye West & Jay‐Z vs. Mariah Carey) | M3rt Mashups | — |
| 22 | I Was Made for Christmas (KISSmas) (Kiss vs. Mariah Carey) | MashGyver | — |
| 23 | All I Want for Christmas 2010 (Mariah Carey vs. Collie Buddz vs. Beatles vs. 2pac vs. REM vs. Usher vs. Bon Jovi) | Mashup-Germany | — |
| 24 | All I Want for Christmas Is Confidence (Demi Lovato vs. Mariah Carey) | MixmstrStel | — |
| 25 | All I Want for Christmas Is Ride (twenty one pilots vs. Mariah Carey) | MixmstrStel | — |
| 26 | All I Want for Christmas x God Is a Woman (Ariana Grande vs. Mariah Carey) | Music Maestro Mashups | — |
| 27 | Christmas 2018 (The Minimix) (Mariah Carey vs. Normani vs. DJ Khalid vs. Ariana Grande vs. Cardi B vs. B. Bunny & J Balvin) | Nmhg | — |
| 28 | Welcome to the Christmas Parade (My Chemical Romance vs. Mariah Carey) | oneboredjeu | — |
| 29 | All I Want for Christmas Is Soulja Boy (Soulja Boy vs. Mariah Carey) | Original Bread | — |
| 30 | All I Want for Christmas Is a Holiday (Green Day vs. Mariah Carey) | Ph0ton | — |
| 31 | All Who We Be for Christmas (DMX vs. Mariah Carey) | Rich | — |
| 32 | All I Want for Christmas Is You x Made You Look (Meghan Trainor vs. Mariah Carey) | Samuel’s Mashups | — |
| 33 | All I Want for Christmas Is to Shake It Off (Taylor Swift vs. Mariah Carey) | S.I.R. | — |
| 34 | Side to Side (All I Want for Christmas Is You) (Ariana Grande & Nicki Minaj vs. Mariah Carey) | S.I.R. | — |
| 35 | All I Want for Christmas Is to Scream & Shout (will.i.am ft. Britney Spears vs. Mariah Carey) | S.I.R. | — |
| 36 | Christmas Baby (Lil Nas X vs. Mariah Carey) | Sijro Mashups | — |
| 37 | All I Want Is Underneath the Tree (Mariah Carey vs. Kelly Clarkson) | SimGiant | — |
| 38 | Can’t Hold Us x All I Want for Christmas Is You (Macklemore vs. Mariah Carey) | Steryish | — |
| 39 | My Only Wish (For Christmas Is You) (Britney Spears vs. Mariah Carey) | #TheFandom | — |
| 40 | We’re Not Gonna Take It – Mariah Carey Christmas Special (Twisted Sister vs. Mariah Carey) | There I Ruined It | — |
| 41 | Can’t Shake Off Christmas Rock (Macklemore vs. Taylor Swift vs. Idina Menzel vs. Bobby Helms vs. Brenda Lee vs. Mariah Carey) | Titus Jones | — |
| 42 | I Want 7 Decked Halls for Christmas (Ihaksi vs. Mariah Carey vs. Ariana Grande) | Titus Jones | — |
| 43 | all i want for christmas is a christmas tree farm (Taylor Swift vs. Mariah Carey) | venice mashups | — |
| 44 | All I Want for Christmas Is to Be Humble (Kendrick Lamar vs. Mariah Carey) | Vincent Mashups | — |
| 45 | All I Want for Christmas Is Killing in the Name (Rage Against the Machine vs Mariah Carey) | vixoria drift | — |
| 46 | All I Want for Christmas Is Money (LISA vs. Mariah Carey) | vixoria drift | — |
| 47 | All I Want for Christmas Is to Feel the Noize (Quiet Riot vs. Mariah Carey) | vixoria drift | — |
| 48 | All I Want for Christmas Is Bow‐Chicka‐Wow‐Wow (Mariah Carey vs. Mike Posner) | Voicedude | — |
| 49 | All I Want for Christmas Is No Mariah Carey (Mariah Carey vs. Shania Twain, Christina Aguilera, Whitney Houston, the Zombies, Black Eyed Peas, Boston, Journey) | Voicedude | — |
| 50 | The Christmash (Mariah Carey vs. Bobby “Boris” Pickett) | William Maranci | — |
| 51 | Creep but It’s All I Want for Christmas (2020 mix) (Radiohead vs. Mariah Carey) | William Maranci | — |
| 52 | For Whom the Bell Tolls but It’s All I Want for Christmas (Metallica vs. Mariah Carey) | William Maranci | — |
| 53 | All I Want for Christmas Is a Ring (Ariana Grande vs. Mariah Carey) | 5 Star Mashups | — |
| 54 | All I Want for Christmas Is the Best Day Ever (Spongebob Squarepants vs. Mariah Carey) | 5 Star Mashups | — |
| 55 | As It Was Christmas (Harry Styles vs. Mariah Carey) | 5 Star Mashups | — |
| 56 | Sucker for Christmas (Jonas Brothers vs. Mariah Carey) | 5 Star Mashups | — |