| A1 | Joy to the World | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| A2 | It Came Upon a Midnight Clear | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| A3 | Angels We Have Heard on High | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| A4 | O Come, o Come, Emanuel | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| A5 | O Little Town of Bethlehem | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| A6 | Silent Night | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| A7 | O Come, All Ye Faithful (Adeste Fideles) | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| A8 | Luther's Cradle Hymn (Away in a Manger) | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| A9 | God Rest You Merry, Gentlemen | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| A10 | We Three Kings | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| A11 | The First Noel | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| A12 | Hark! The Herald Angels Sing | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B1 | Shepherd's Carol (Carol From the Suffolk Harmony, 1786) | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B2 | Coventry Carol | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B3 | Patapan | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B4 | My Dancing Day | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B5 | I Wonder as I Wander (Appalachian Folk Song) | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B6 | Bring a Torch, Jeanette, Isabella | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B7 | Carol of the Bells | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B8 | Lo, How a Rose E'Er Blooming | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B9 | Go Tell It on the Mountain | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B10 | I Sing of a Maiden (15th Century Carol) | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B11 | Echo Hymn (17th Century Melody) | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B12 | Wassail Song | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |
| B13 | Deck the Halls With Boughs of Holly | Robert Shaw Chorale | — |