| 1 | Please, Please, Please Let Me Get What I Want (2011 remastered version) | The Smiths | — |
| 2 | Santa’s Kiss (full version) | Jay Price | — |
| 3 | I Don’t Intend to Spend Christmas Without You | Margo Guryan | — |
| 4 | The Greatest Gift | Sufjan Stevens | — |
| 5 | Frosty the Snowman | Cocteau Twins | — |
| 6 | Diamonds in Moonlight (full version) | Harvey L. Summers | — |
| 7 | Christmas | Clinic | — |
| 8 | Christmas Time Is Here | Khruangbin | — |
| 9 | Christmas Card From a Hooker in Minneapolis | Tom Waits | — |
| 10 | Feliz Navidad | shame | — |
| 11 | Lonely Man of Winter | Sufjan Stevens | — |
| 12 | Long Way Around the Sea | Low | — |
| 13 | Snow Baby (full version) | Philip Hochstrate | — |
| 14 | She Came Home for Christmas | Mew | — |
| 15 | Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas | Phoebe Bridgers | — |
| 16 | White Winter Hymnal | Fleet Foxes | — |
| 17 | Blue Christmas | Creeper | — |
| 18 | Happy Xmas (War Is Over) | John Lennon, The Harlem Community Choir, Plastic Ono Band & Yoko Ono | — |
| 19 | Christmas at the Zoo | The Flaming Lips | — |
| 20 | When Gloves Come Off | Tyler, The Creator feat. Ryan Beatty | — |
| 21 | Christmas Wrapping | Summer Camp | — |
| 22 | Kindle a Flame in Her Heart | Los Campesinos! | — |
| 23 | Christmas Song | The Aislers Set | — |
| 24 | The Christmas Song | Bob Dylan | — |
| 25 | We Three Kings | Patti Smith | — |
| 26 | Blue Christmas | Bright Eyes | — |
| 27 | Xmas in Alaska (full version) | Harvey L. Summers | — |
| 28 | I Wish It Was Christmas Today | Julian Casablancas | — |
| 29 | Is This Christmas? (radio edit) | The Wombats | — |
| 30 | And Anyway It’s Christmas | !!! | — |
| 31 | Reindeer | The Knife | — |
| 32 | Christmastime | The Smashing Pumpkins | — |
| 33 | Christmas Unicorn | Sufjan Stevens | — |
| 34 | Alone on Christmas Day | Phoenix | — |
| 35 | Xmas in Alaska (underscore) | Harvey L. Summers | — |
| 36 | A Change at Christmas (Say It Isn’t So) | The Flaming Lips | — |
| 37 | Christmas Wrapping (single edit) | The Waitresses | — |
| 38 | Listen, the Snow Is Falling | Galaxie 500 | — |
| 39 | Coming Home for Christmas (30 seconds) | Jay Price | — |
| 40 | Snow in Sun | Scritti Politti | — |
| 41 | Wonderful Christmastime | The Shins | — |
| 42 | Up on the Housetop | Sufjan Stevens | — |
| 43 | Just Like Christmas | Low | — |
| 44 | Auld Lang Syne | Andrew Bird | — |
| 45 | Come Thou Fount of Every Blessing | Sufjan Stevens | — |
| 46 | Christmas Is Going to the Dogs | EELS | — |
| 47 | Bad Cover Version | Pulp | — |
| 48 | A Christmas Duel | The Hives & Cyndi Lauper | — |
| 49 | (We Wish You) A Protein Christmas | The Fall | — |
| 50 | Only at Christmas Time | Sufjan Stevens | — |
| 51 | Merry Christmas | Silkworm | — |
| 52 | Cold Out There | Jon Hopkins | — |
| 53 | All I Want for Christmas Is New Year’s Day | Hurts | — |
| 54 | Frosty the Snowman | Fiona Apple | — |
| 55 | Christmas Will Break Your Heart | LCD Soundsystem | — |
| 56 | The Only Time I’m Home | Tom Rosenthal | — |
| 57 | Christmas Canoodle (underscore) | Jay Price | — |
| 58 | Under the Mistletoe (30 seconds) | Alex Wilson | — |
| 59 | Christmas Song | Phoebe Bridgers | — |