| 1 | Cabaret (Cabaret) | Jill Haworth | — |
| 2 | If I Were a Rich Man (Fiddler on the Roof) | Zero Mostel | — |
| 3 | Oh, What a Beautiful Morning (Oklahoma!) | Laurence Guittard | — |
| 4 | Climb Ev’ry Mountain (The Sound of Music) | Patricia Neway | — |
| 5 | Big Spender (Sweet Charity) | Helen Gallagher & Thelma Oliver | — |
| 6 | Getting to Know You (The King and I) | Risë Stevens | — |
| 7 | ’Tis Harry I’m Plannin’ to Marry (Calamity Jane) | Doris Day | — |
| 8 | There’s No Business Like Show Business (Annie Get Your Gun) | Louis Calhern | — |
| 9 | Ohio (Wonderful Town) | Sydney Chaplin & Rosalind Russell | — |
| 10 | We’re in the Money (42nd Street) | Karen Prunczik | — |
| 11 | Half a Sixpence (Half a Sixpence) | Tommy Steele & Polly James | — |
| 12 | If He Walked Into My Life (Mame) | Angela Lansbury | — |
| 13 | Put on a Happy Face (Bye Bye Birdie) | Dick Van Dyke | — |
| 14 | Ol’ Man River (Showboat) | William Warfield | — |
| 15 | Honey Bun (South Pacific) | Mary Martin | — |
| 16 | Once-A-Year Day! (The Pajama Game) | John Raitt | — |
| 17 | I Could Be Happy With You (The Boy Friend) | Julie Andrews & John Hewer | — |
| 18 | Day by Day (Godspell) | Robin Lamont | — |
| 19 | Standing on the Corner (Most Happy Fella) | Bob Freschi | — |
| 20 | Overture / Ballad of Mack the Knife (The Threepenny Opera) | Roy Brocksmith | — |